Understanding Pilot Decision-Making Failures in Adverse Weather: An HFACS and Bowtie Diagram Analysis of Helicopter Accidents
- Douglas Casale
- Dante Ricardo Ambrosio
- Mírian Kelly Miranda Drago
- Moacyr Machado Cardoso Júnior
- Luís Eduardo Vergueiro Loures da Costa
Aeronautics Institute of Technology
- Event
- XXII SITRAER – Brasília, DF, Brasil, October 22–24, 2025
- Volume
- Anais do XXII Simpósio de Transporte Aéreo – SITRAER 2025 · ISBN 978-65-272-2024-4 · DOI 10.29327/9786527220244
- Publisher
- Even3 Publicações
- Editors
- Fabiana Serra de Arruda, Camila Lucena, Giovanna Miceli Ronzani Borille, Evandro José da Silva
Abstract
Aviation safety is maintained through rigorous adherence to established standards. However, certain pressure situations can compromise operational safety, making crews take unreasonable risk, like flying under adverse weather conditions. This paper aims to analyze helicopter accidents occurring in meteorological scenarios where flights should have been avoided, identifying patterns that influence pilots’ misjudgment. This work uses two analytical frameworks: the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (HFACS) and Bowtie diagrams, applied to four selected helicopter accident cases. The HFACS model systematically categorizes failures at four hierarchical levels (Organizational Influences, Unsafe Supervision, Preconditions for Unsafe Acts, and Unsafe Acts) whereas Bowtie diagrams visually map threats, preventive barriers, the critical top event, and mitigation barriers related to the accidents. The results consistently revealed organizational and selfimposed pressures influencing the decision-making of pilots to proceed under unsafe weather conditions, but these decisions were also shaped by additional factors, such as inadequate training, insufficient operational oversight, fatigue, poor risk perception, spatial disorientation, and misuse of onboard instruments, such as the meteorological radar. The Bowtie diagrams highlighted latent conditions, the inadequacy or absence of safety barriers, and the critical short timeframe available for mitigating actions once control was lost. The study concludes that enhancing organizational oversight, structured training, and proper understanding of avionic systems, particularly weather radar capabilities and limitations, are important to preventing similar accidents in the future.
Keywords: HFACS; Bowtie Diagram; Aeronautical Accidents; Flight Safety